Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

Not everyone likes thinking about their toilet, but studies have shown that some of us can spend as much as 92 days or more on the toilet in our lifetimes! We spend a lot of time on our “thrones” so it’s important for us to be as informed as possible when searching for the best toilet seat. 

You might think that toilets seats are all the same because their construction is so simple, but with the technology and materials available today you have a lot more options than you may think. We’re here to explain those options so you can find the best toilet seat for you.

Below, we’ve highlighted a few of the best products out there and have illustrated what we particularly like about each one as well as what we feel could be better.

Top Picks For Best Toilet Seat

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B00NAHULPE&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=lh roundup 20 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018ir?t=lh roundup 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B00NAHULPE - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
Bath Royale Premium Elongated Toilet Seat
As the name suggests this toilet seat is a higher end model made from high quality plastic with a sturdy construction. Another key feature is its 1-Touch Quick Release system which makes installation and cleaning a snap.
Price range: $50 - $60

*at the time of publishing

barcode - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

ABOUT THIS PRODUCT

Bath Royale Premium Elongated Toilet Seat is a bit higher on the price spectrum, but you get a lot of quality for the price you pay. It’s designed to last and can handle up to 400 lbs.

The Bath Royale is made of quality plastic, so it may not feel as soft as a wood toilet seat. However, the high grade polypropylene should last longer and is much less likely to chip, crack, fade or stain.

It’s got a lot of great features including Soft Close, which prevents the seat from slamming down and potentially breaking. You also don’t need to bend over to lower it making it easy to use for kids, the elderly or people with back pain.

The 1-Touch release system makes it simple to detach from the bowl for cleaning and doesn’t require excessive screwing or fastening. We thought it was great not needing too many tools.

Many reviewers appreciated the clear instructions and ease of installation. Owners who clean frequently love how easy the seat comes off for fast cleaning.

This ease of release, however, might just be too easy according to some reports of the seat shifting around too much after long term use. Some reviewers have also complained that they couldn’t get the toilet seat to stay in place after installation.

pros - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE LIKED
  • High quality materials and construction
  • Easy to remove for cleaning
  • Soft Close works well
cons - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE DON'T LIKE
  • A bit on the expensive side
  • Can move around a lot if not securely fastened
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B001AHPKXO&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=lh roundup 20 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018ir?t=lh roundup 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B001AHPKXO - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
Comfort Seats C1B1E-17BN Designer Solid Wood Toilet Seat
Beautiful design and appearance
Quality materials
Price range: $40 - $50

*at the time of publishing

barcode - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

ABOUT THIS PRODUCT

This decorative model, Comfort Seats C1B1E-17BN Designer Solid Wood Toilet Seat is made of solid, 100 percent natural oak. The manufacturer also makes similar models with different wooden finishes if your bathroom décor calls for it.

Conventional wisdom says that wooden seats are not as hardy as plastic but these seats generally use cheap wood. This model, however, uses especially high quality wood when compared with flimsier materials of other molded wood toilet seats.

The finish on this toilet seat is fine yet thick lacquer. This prevents a lot of wear and tear as well as microbial buildup but also might detract from its authentic wooden look.

The hinges are made of brushed nickel which are attractive, but the nature of metal hinges could make for difficult installation and removal. Similar models from Comfort Seats come with brass hinges if that’s the look you want.

Many reviewers were impressed with the quality material and craftsmanship. Most did not mind paying a little extra more for a better looking toilet seat.

Some owners, though, have reported that this toilet seat does not fit on some models of toilet, causing some problems. For example, reviewers have discovered that this toilet seat is ¼ inch too short for Kohler brand elongated toilets making it difficult to handle when lifting it up.

pros - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE LIKED
  • Expensive
  • Problems fitting some toilets
cons - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE DON'T LIKE
  • Expensive
  • Problems fitting some toilets
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B000TD4QLM&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=lh roundup 20 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018ir?t=lh roundup 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B000TD4QLM - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
Mayfair 148SLOWA 000/1848SLOWA 000
A mid-range toilet seat that opens and closes quietly and slowly stopping slams and finger pinches. A durable finish resists wear and scratching.
Price range: $20 - $30

*at the time of publishing

barcode - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

ABOUT THIS PRODUCT

A good mid-range model, this Mayfair has good value. Its features allow it to perform similar to higher end toilet seats at a lower price.

The Whisper-Close lid is very quiet and slow enough that you won’t get your fingers caught under if it accidentally starts closing. Like more expensive models, you can simply tap this lid and walk away as it silently and slowly makes its way down.

This Mayfair model also boasts easy installation and removal for cleaning. You can rotate both securing latches on the lid and remove it without the need for any tools.

The main drawback of this toilet seat is its material, which is molded wood. It isn’t as durable as plastic or even other solid wood models and is prone to cracking.

Also, the seat may accumulate stains or microbial buildup, especially on the underside. Even with regular cleaning, the cleaning materials themselves can leave stains or scratches.

Customers who bought this toilet seat loved the Whisper-Close feature and the easy installation and removal. The price was also a high point, coming in at half the price of some premium models.

Unfortunately, many buyers reported it breaking or cracking after less than a year of use which may be a result of improper installation or too much weight. Customers also noticed that the finish wears and stains faster than other more durable seats after heavy use.

pros - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE LIKED
  • Great price for value
  • Whisper-Close works great
  • Easy installation and removal
cons - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE DON'T LIKE
  • Relatively fragile material
  • Might not last as long as more expensive models
BEST TOILET SEAT
product fourth place - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B000TFHN56&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=lh roundup 20 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018ir?t=lh roundup 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B000TFHN56 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
KOHLER K-4636-0 Cachet
A hardy model with a good design. This name brand toilet seat is packed with features.
Price range: $35 - $45

*at the time of publishing

barcode - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

ABOUT THIS PRODUCT

Kohler is a trusted name brand and this is one of their top selling toilet seats. It is chock full of features you would expect from a well-known company.

Its Quiet-Close feature functions similar to other models and works great. Grip tight bumpers stop it from sliding during use.

Quick-Attach and Quick-Release technology makes for fast and easy installation and removal, but the hinge construction isn’t as strong as others. Like the rest of the seat, much of the hinge system is made of plastic and could be prone to breaking.

The plastic construction makes this seat more resistant to wear, but it also makes it less comfortable. The thin plastic and rounded seat might not be for everyone.

The many well-functioning design features were a highlight of customers’ reviews. Buyers also appreciated the name brand quality and look for a decent price.

One of the main complaints some owners had was the comfort; the hard plastic and funnel-like shape of the seat turned many people off. Other owners found that this Kohler toilet seat did not connect well to their toilet and some parts of the hinges would break.

pros - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE LIKED
  • A lot of features that function as advertised
  • Name brand quality for a good price
cons - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE DON'T LIKE
  • Not as comfortable as other models
  • Hinge system not as sturdy and some components are prone to breaks.
BEST TOILET SEAT
product fifth place - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B002R5B1CW&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=lh roundup 20 - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018ir?t=lh roundup 20&l=li3&o=1&a=B002R5B1CW - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
Bemis 500EC000
A comfortable toilet seat that is exceptionally easy to install. This one gives a lot of value for its reasonable price.
Price range: $15 - $25

*at the time of publishing

barcode - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

ABOUT THIS PRODUCT

If you aren’t looking to spend a whole lot on your toilet seat, this model is a great option. Comfortable and simple, this no frills seat is especially suited for bulk buys or toilets that do not see heavy use like those in guest rooms.

The molded wood material is soft to the touch but, as with other seats made from this material, it suffers from drawbacks like being scratch prone and having a reduced load capacity.

This Bemis model doesn’t sport fancy features like slow or quiet close, but it’s still well put together. It is sturdy and has twist hinges for easy detachment.

The Bemis 500EC0000 can be installed in as little as five minutes so if you’re not into DIY or don’t want to spend time figuring out a toilet seat this is a good choice. It’s nothing special, but it just works.

Owners of this toilet seat find that the quality is excellent when compared with the price. This was a perfect fit for customers looking for a low cost, simple, comfortable and easy to manage toilet seat.

The main problems that reviewers had with this product were with its lifespan. Cracking, scratching, fading and premature detachment all from overuse were some common complaints.

pros - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE LIKED
  • Great value for a low price
  • Comfortable
  • No frills, easy to install
cons - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018
WHAT WE DON'T LIKE
  • Short lifespan; prone to wear and tear
  • No slow or quiet close
lshl process - Best Toilet Seat Reviews – 2018

What to Look for When Shopping for the Best Toilet Seat

The best toilet seat for you will depend on a few things. It may seem like a minor purchase, but this is an item you’ll be using possibly daily for hopefully a long time so a little consideration now will save you time later on down the road.

Before choosing any toilet seat though, the first thing you should find out is if your toilet is a “round” model toilet that is circle shaped or an “elongated” toilet which is shaped like an oval. If you aren’t sure just by looking at your toilet, simply measure the toilet bowl from the front to the back in the middle of the seat screw fixtures.

  • Round Bowl: About 16.5 inches.
  • Elongated Bowl: About 18.5 inches.

Material

There are a couple options when it comes to material for your toilet seat. How you intend to use it and your preferences should play a part in your decision-making process.

  • Wood – Often referred to as molded wood in product descriptions, wood toilet seats offer superior warmth and comfort. However as wood is porous and requires a finish, it is possible that the finish can scratch off or fade away exposing the wood to stains and bacteria which can cause odors.
  • Plastic – In general, plastic seats are made of tough polypropylene that have a longer expected lifespan with high use and is much more difficult to scuff, crack or stain. Some consider plastic seats to be uncomfortable when compared with wooden ones though, especially if cold toilet seats are a problem.

Features to Consider

Today’s toilet seats come with many features you may not be accustomed to.

  • Slow/Quiet Close – Some toilet seats employ systems that make the lid and seat close slowly regardless of gravity to stop slams or accidental injury.
  • Quick Release – These systems use swiveling or twisting latches that make it easier to remove without tools but are less secure and may lead to slippage and loosening.

Conclusion

We found that the toilet seat that has the best of these qualities is the Bath Royale Premium Elongated Toilet Seat. It has the best collection of features and design at a very reasonable price.

Its high quality polypropylene construction will last a long time and will prevent a lot of potential problems such as breaks. Great features like 1-Touch Release and Soft-Close are well worth the cost.

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: